Isabelle Gitlin Confronts Regret and the Weight of the Past on New Single “Rumination”


Boston-based pop and soul artist Isabelle Gitlin is exploring the emotional consequences of living in the past with her latest single, “Rumination.” Blending introspective songwriting with an increasingly unraveling musical arrangement, Gitlin delivers a deeply personal reflection on regret, missed opportunities, and the exhausting desire to rewrite moments that can never be changed.
Written as a letter from her present self to her younger self, “Rumination” examines the dangerous space between healthy reflection and obsessive overthinking. It's a familiar struggle: replaying old decisions, imagining alternate outcomes, and convincing ourselves that life would somehow be better if we'd taken a different path.
What makes “Rumination” particularly compelling is how Gitlin uses the song's progression to mirror its emotional subject matter. As the lyrics become increasingly consumed by regret, the production begins to unravel alongside them, reflecting how quickly a single thought can spiral into something much harder to escape.
Rather than offering an easy resolution, Gitlin allows that discomfort to exist, capturing the reality of feeling stuck between who you were and who you wish you'd become.“My hope is that people feel less alone and weighed down by mistakes or ‘feeling behind’ in life,” Gitlin shares. “We're all on our own paths, and the past doesn't determine your future.”
Following previous releases including “For Tonight,” “Long & Gone,” and “Running Circles,” Gitlin continues to develop an artistic identity rooted in emotional honesty and thoughtful storytelling. “Rumination” serves as a reminder that constantly revisiting the life you could have lived can prevent you from appreciating the one you're still building.
Listen to Isabelle Gitlin's “Rumination,” available now on Spotify and major streaming platforms.
“Rumination” is written as a letter to your younger self, confronting regret and the desire to rewrite the past. If you could actually sit across from that younger version of yourself today, what's the one truth you'd tell her that she probably wouldn't want to hear?
That’s hard! I’d probably say to her that you’re not going to wake up one day and have all the answers. When I was younger, I thought that when I got older I’d have everything figured out, but nothing is that simple.
There's a fine line between learning from your mistakes and allowing them to define your identity. Was there a particular experience that made you realize you were no longer reflecting on your past but actually allowing it to hold you back?
There are many, and most of them are very internal for me. I’d say overall, the experiences I’ve had where I’ve held back out of fear and doubt are big ones. Self-doubt is strong; I feel it physically, and ever since I was a kid, it’s stifled me more times than I can count. Thinking of how I should’ve done something differently, or if I’d known this or that, etc., can become very destructive because you start living in the past instead of focusing on and embracing the present.
Throughout “Rumination,” the lyrics and production progressively unravel, mirroring the way overthinking can spiral out of control. How intentional was that creative decision, and what did you want listeners to experience emotionally as the song became increasingly intense?
That was a very intentional decision; I wanted the lyrics to become more direct as the song went on and for the production to grow into something almost messy. I also wanted to have more vocal stacks as the song progressed to emphasize the strength of the ruminations and to represent all the times you’ve had the same conversation with yourself; the more you feed into the thoughts, the stronger they become.
Generally, I’ve always struggled with dancing around the point, and so with the song, my goal was to be honest. The bridge for me is the most raw part, and I knew I needed to build up to that moment where there’s really nothing left to hide. Ultimately, I wanted listeners to experience that loss of control that comes with nonstop ruminating, where there are no resolutions, and there’s no definite end.
We're living in a culture obsessed with milestones, success, and having everything figured out by a certain age. Do you think the pressure to be further ahead in life has made it harder for your generation to appreciate where they actually are?
Yes, I really do. It’s hard because I think that we become so obsessed with the result that we forget about the journey. We only ever see people’s successes but not the work, failures, and time it took to get there.
It can become so suffocating that you end up wanting to hit milestones for the sake of hitting milestones, but we have to appreciate that the process, the growth, the learning- all of that is necessary to get to where you want to go; it’s where the majority of the time is spent. It’s difficult, but I’m personally trying to be more comfortable with embracing that and being ok with not having the “perfect” timeline. I think there is beauty in carving your own path and taking the time you need to get there.
Your music often explores uncomfortable emotions that people struggle to acknowledge openly. Has songwriting genuinely helped you make peace with your past, or have there been moments when turning those experiences into music forced you to confront things you thought you'd already moved on from?
It’s definitely both. The process of songwriting helps me pinpoint and verbalize thoughts and feelings that I otherwise internalize or keep to myself. That is what allows me to make peace with the things that I’ve carried with me and continue to carry with me. Every project is different, though; some are more inspired by my inner world, others come from an outside inspiration. Either way, it’s cathartic for me, and it’s a piece of me I get to share.
%20WHITE.png)


